Connect with us

Sports Betting

KALSHI LOSES FOURTH CIRCUIT APPEAL AS SPLIT PANEL BACKS MARYLAND

A divided Fourth Circuit panel upheld the denial of Kalshi’s preliminary injunction against Maryland’s gambling regulators, deepening the circuit split over sports event contracts.

Published

on

Kalshi logo

Kalshi has lost its appeal against Maryland’s gambling regulators at the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, which on 17 November upheld a lower court’s refusal to block the state from enforcing its sports wagering laws against the prediction market operator.

The three-judge panel split 2-1. A one-line published per curiam opinion affirmed the August 2025 decision of US District Judge Adam Abelson in Baltimore to deny Kalshi a preliminary injunction. Judges Roger Gregory and Stephanie Thacker voted to affirm, while Judge DeAndrea Benjamin dissented.

The ruling does not settle the case on its merits. It means Maryland, which sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter in April 2025, is not barred from enforcing its laws while the underlying lawsuit continues.

Two routes to the same result

The majority judges reached the same outcome by different reasoning, and the court issued no single rationale.

Judge Gregory declined to decide whether Kalshi’s sports event contracts are “swaps” under the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA), the question at the centre of the industry’s preemption argument. Even assuming they are, he concluded that neither the CEA nor Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) rules clearly entitle them to trade free of state gaming law. Gambling is a traditional state police power, he wrote, and Kalshi had not shown that Congress intended to displace it.

“Congress knows how to displace traditional state police powers when it chooses to do so,” Judge Gregory wrote in his concurrence.

Judge Thacker went further, concurring in the judgment on the basis that Kalshi’s sports contracts are not swaps at all and therefore fall outside the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction. Her opinion drew on the Ninth Circuit’s August ruling in Kalshi’s Nevada case, which reached the same view.

Judge Benjamin took the opposite position. The dissent concluded that the contracts are swaps, that the CEA gives the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over them and that Maryland’s laws are therefore field preempted. Judge Benjamin would have vacated the injunction denial and sent the case back to the district court.

Reaction from both sides

Kalshi said the split decision “demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets,” according to Reuters. Jeremy Baker, who leads Maryland’s lottery and gaming regulator, said the ruling “affirmed the state’s ability to regulate what is clearly sports wagering.”

Maryland was backed on appeal by amicus briefs from Nevada, Ohio and 36 other states plus the District of Columbia, as well as the American Gaming Association, tribal gaming groups and Better Markets. Kalshi’s supporters included the investment firm Paradigm and the fantasy and prediction operator Underdog.

A widening circuit split

The Fourth Circuit joins the Sixth Circuit, which let states regulate Kalshi’s sports contracts in a ruling earlier this year, and the Ninth Circuit in rejecting Kalshi’s preemption claims. The Third Circuit is the outlier, having sided with Kalshi against New Jersey over a dissent.

That disagreement is already in front of the Supreme Court, where 39 states have urged the justices to hear New Jersey’s appeal. Reuters said the latest split increases the odds that the Supreme Court will be forced to take up the issue.

The Maryland loss lands during a difficult month for Kalshi on the regulatory front. The CFTC, which under its current leadership shares the industry’s view that federal law governs event contracts, warned the company of imminent charges over its contract filings last week, and several states have escalated civil and criminal actions.

Kalshi can seek rehearing by the full Fourth Circuit or petition the Supreme Court. No filing had been reported by the time of publication.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sports Betting

TABCORP DEFENDS BETMAKERS DEAL ON CUSTOMER DATA AS IT CUTS 50 TECH ROLES

Tabcorp CEO Gillon McLachlan says the A$267m BetMakers takeover will not give it rivals’ customer data, as the group cuts about 50 technology roles ahead of an ACCC ruling due on 3 December.

Published

on

Tabcorp Defends Betmakers Deal On Customer Data As It Cuts 50 Tech Roles

Tabcorp chief executive Gillon McLachlan has sought to reassure rival bookmakers that the group’s planned takeover of BetMakers Technology Group will not give it access to their customer data. Separately, the ASX-listed wagering operator has cut around 50 technology roles as it prepares to integrate the business.

McLachlan told the Australian Financial Review that the deal would not hand Tabcorp access to competitors’ customer information, according to market wraps citing the newspaper on 16 November. The comments address a concern that has followed the transaction since it was announced in August: around 50 bookmakers rely on BetMakers technology, and some smaller operators fear that its new owner would be able to see who their customers are.

The deal

Tabcorp agreed on 10 August to acquire all of BetMakers (ASX: BET) through a scheme of arrangement at A$0.24 cash per share, according to its announcement to the ASX. BetMakers shareholders can elect to take part of their consideration in new Tabcorp shares, with total scrip capped at 25% and issued at no less than A$1.00 per share.

The offer values BetMakers at about A$282.9m on a fully diluted equity basis and A$267.3m at enterprise value, a 45.5% premium to its closing price before the announcement. Tabcorp is targeting A$30m in run-rate cost synergies by the end of the second year of ownership and expects the deal to add to earnings per share from year two, by double digits from year three.

“Combining BetMakers’ business with our rights, content and customer relationships creates a differentiated offering,” McLachlan said when the deal was announced. Tabcorp has described the business as a future global B2B growth engine, particularly for its media and tote operations. BetMakers’ Global Betting Services division, which supplies odds creation, bet processing and risk management technology to bookmakers, accounted for about 40% of its FY25 revenue.

Competition review

The data question goes to the heart of the competition review. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission’s acquisitions register notes that BetMakers supplies fixed-odds technology to wagering operators that compete with Tabcorp. The deal was notified on 15 October and is in Phase 1 of the ACCC’s assessment. The timeline was extended by five business days at the parties’ request on 9 November, and a determination is now due on 3 December.

The scheme also requires gaming and racing approvals in several jurisdictions, BetMakers shareholder approval and court sign-off. It does not need a vote by Tabcorp shareholders, and completion is targeted for the January to March 2027 quarter.

Technology roles cut

Tabcorp confirmed to The Straight that about 50 full-time positions, plus a number of contractors, have been cut. Most are technology roles, including developers, quality assurance and production support staff working on TAB apps. The Straight linked the cuts to the A$30m synergy target. They came straight after the Melbourne Cup Carnival, the busiest period of the Australian racing calendar.

The ACCC’s ruling on 3 December is the next major milestone. A clearance would leave the scheme booklet and shareholder vote as the main remaining hurdles before Tabcorp takes control of one of the main technology suppliers to its own competitors.

Continue Reading

Sports Betting

NSW REGULATOR WEIGHS PROSECUTION OF LARGE BOOKMAKER OVER INDUCEMENT ADS

Liquor & Gaming NSW has told bookmakers that ‘not available in NSW’ disclaimers do not excuse inducement ads, and says it is considering prosecuting a large operator over repeated bonus credit offers.

Published

on

Nsw Regulator Weighs Prosecution Of Large Bookmaker Over Inducement Ads

Liquor & Gaming NSW (L&GNSW) has warned licensed bookmakers that disclaimers saying an offer is unavailable in New South Wales will not protect them from the state’s ban on gambling inducements. The regulator also said it is weighing enforcement action, including a possible prosecution, against a large wagering operator.

The warning appears in the regulator’s Hospitality and Racing Newsletter, published on 16 November. It restates a compliance notice that L&GNSW issued to betting service providers on 29 October as the spring racing carnival got under way. The newsletter says gambling ads accessible in NSW must not include inducements such as bonus credits, vouchers or rewards, “even where disclaimers state offers are unavailable in NSW”.

A large operator in the frame

The most pointed line in the October notice concerns a single, unnamed operator. “L&GNSW is currently considering enforcement action, including potential prosecution, against a large BSP who has repeatedly advertised inducements such as bonus credits,” the regulator said. Neither L&GNSW nor The Straight, which reported the renewed warning on 17 November, has identified the company.

Section 33H of the Betting and Racing Act 1998 prohibits gambling advertising accessible in NSW that offers an inducement to gamble, to gamble more often, or to open a betting account. The notice lists credit or bonus offers, vouchers, rewards programmes and “gambling products or features that provide additional benefits” among the practices caught by the ban.

The maximum penalty is 1,000 penalty units for a corporation and 100 for an individual, equivalent to A$110,000 and A$11,000. Directors and officers can also be held liable, and the regulator can issue penalty notices instead of going to court.

The regulator also made clear that the busy racing calendar offers no cover. “Increased commercial or operational pressures associated with major racing events do not excuse non-compliance,” it said.

Statutory notices also under scrutiny

The notice carried a second warning about how bookmakers deal with information requests. L&GNSW said responses to statutory notices issued under section 21 of the Gaming and Liquor Administration Act 2007 had been poor. Failing to comply with such a notice is an offence carrying a maximum of 100 penalty units, and the regulator said partial, late or deficient responses may count as non-compliance. It expects senior executives to oversee the process.

Track record

NSW has pursued inducement breaches before, though the largest operators have rarely been on the receiving end in recent years. In April 2023 L&GNSW issued Betr with 14 penalty notices of A$15,000 each, a total of A$210,000, over enhanced-odds offers on the Melbourne Cup, Cox Plate, NRL and AFL during its launch. In January 2024 SportChamps was fined A$17,500 in the Downing Centre Local Court over free-bet ads, its sixth such penalty. Earlier cases include a A$60,000 fine for Unibet’s Betchoice brand in 2019 and a A$15,000 fine for Tabcorp published in 2023.

The renewed warning comes as Australian wagering advertising faces wider tightening, with federal online advertising restrictions due to take effect from 1 January 2027, according to The Straight. Any prosecution of a major bookmaker under section 33H would be the most significant inducement case in the state for several years.

Continue Reading

Sports Betting

NINE SENATE DEMOCRATS PRESS CFTC TO DROP PREDICTION MARKET GEOFENCING ORDER

Nine Democratic senators led by Adam Schiff have asked the CFTC to withdraw its order telling prediction markets to stop geofencing banned states, as an AGA poll finds 82% of Americans want the markets regulated as gambling.

Published

on

Nine Senate Democrats Press Cftc To Drop Prediction Market Geofencing Order

Nine Democratic US senators have called on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to withdraw its order telling prediction markets to stop geofencing states where sports event contracts are banned, warning that the agency is encouraging platforms to defy active court orders.

The letter, sent on 16 November to CFTC chairman Michael Selig, was led by California senator Adam Schiff. It was co-signed by Alex Padilla of California, Catherine Cortez Masto and Jacky Rosen of Nevada, Maria Cantwell and Patty Murray of Washington, Elissa Slotkin and Gary Peters of Michigan, and Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota, the ranking member of the Senate Agriculture Committee, which oversees the CFTC.

“Your unilateral decision directly conflicts with active court orders, undermines state and tribal law, and must be reversed,” the senators wrote, according to copies of the letter reported by CoinDesk and CDC Gaming.

The 30-day order

The dispute centres on an interpretation of the CFTC’s impartial access requirements that the agency issued on 5 November. It told designated contract markets that they “must cease domestic geographic restrictions” that breach those requirements within 30 days, or explain to the Division of Market Oversight why they cannot. Exchanges must also make sure that intermediaries such as futures commission merchants are not blocking access.

Selig said at the time that geographic access restrictions were inconsistent with the Commodity Exchange Act. The order, which gave platforms 30 days to drop state geofencing, would in effect require operators such as Kalshi and Polymarket to serve users in states that have obtained injunctions against them.

The senators pointed to court orders in Michigan, Nevada and Washington, and on the lands of two California tribes. “The Commission now appears to be encouraging prediction markets to offer prohibited contracts in contempt of these court orders during active litigation,” they wrote.

They asked the CFTC either to withdraw the interpretation or to freeze all efforts to implement it until the litigation is resolved. They also asked the agency to preserve all records and communications on the subject from 1 January 2025 and to confirm by 23 November that it is doing so, a request that signals possible oversight work once Democrats take control of the Senate Agriculture Committee in the new Congress.

The CFTC had not published a response by Tuesday morning. The agency filed suits against Arkansas and Louisiana on 13 November, and Louisiana’s attorney general has called Selig’s claims “flatly false”.

AGA poll lands the same day

The letter coincided with the American Gaming Association’s annual American Attitudes Toward Gaming survey, which the trade body released on 16 November. The online survey of 2,268 registered voters aged 21 and over, conducted on Qualtrics between 2 and 18 September, found that 82% believe prediction markets should be regulated as gambling rather than financial products, with little variation between Democrats (84%), Republicans (82%) and independents (80%).

Three-quarters of respondents said a sports bet on a prediction market was fundamentally the same as one placed with a sportsbook, while half wrongly believed prediction markets were state-licensed sportsbooks. Majorities backed age verification at 21, responsible gambling messaging in advertising, state gaming licences and the honouring of state self-exclusion lists.

AGA president and chief executive Bill Miller singled out Kalshi’s marketing. “Insidiously misrepresenting sports betting as an investment to 18-year-olds, and telling them it can pay their rent or college tuition, is a grotesque business practice,” he said.

The CFTC’s 30-day window runs to early December, setting up a direct clash between the federal regulator, state courts and a Congress in which pressure on the agency is growing on both sides of the prediction markets fight.

Continue Reading

Trending